Cabinets vs. Open Shelving  – Which is better for your kitchen

Cabinets-vsPic-01.jpg
DATE Post 1 INSIDE Post 1.jpg

Are you one of the many homeowners considering a kitchen remodel in 2022? At one point, cabinets were the norm, so much so that a renovator may not have even considered an alternative. More recently, open shelves became a popular kitchen trend. While there is some dispute about the longevity of this style, open shelving has long been used in American kitchens, as Apartment Therapy’s Nancy Mitchell points out in her piece, “The Surprising History of a “New” Trend that isn’t New at All.” Understandably, you will find passionate designers and homeowners on both sides of the kitchen cabinets vs. open shelves debate. All of which to say, the choice is ultimately about YOU – how you use your kitchen, how you decorate, how you clean, and so forth. We’ll explore the pros and cons of each product as well as ways to combine the benefits of both.

  1. Why are cabinets the go-to option for so many homeowners?

  2. Are there any downsides to traditional kitchen cupboards?

  3. Why are open shelves preferred by some designers and families?

  4. What materials are kitchen shelves made of?

  5. Are there disadvantages to wall shelves in a kitchen?

  6. How could I mitigate these disadvantages if I really want to try open shelving?

  7. What if I like the benefits of open shelving but am not ready to tear out any cabinets?

  8. Do shelves or cabinets harmonize better with certain types of décor?

  9. What is the best way to arrange items on open shelves?

  10. How can I tastefully style items behind clear glass door fronts?

  11. How can I learn more about the process of adding glass shelves or cabinet glass to my particular kitchen?

1. Why are cabinets the go-to options for so many homeowners?

right-form-abc-mockup-2.jpg
 
Cabinets-vsPic-02.jpg

The matching built-in cabinets we’re used to today were not always the norm. A perusal of old kitchen drawings and photos highlights the fact that open shelves and furniture style cabinets were utilized simultaneously within one kitchen. As Mike Jackson points out in “The Rise of the Modern Kitchen,” early kitchen cupboards were small free-standing units. It was in the 1920s that uniform, modular cabinetry was introduced and steadily grew in popularity. 

What has given this approach such staying power that it remains the go-to for many designers?

  • Built-in cabinet systems are professionally designed with an eye to convenience and efficiency.

  • You don’t have to dust and sweep beneath built-in cupboards like you have to with many free-standing pieces.

  • Kitchen cabinet systems seek to maximize storage space and accessibility.

  • Matching cabinets give your kitchen a harmonious and unified look that is appealing to many decorators.

  • Most cabinets have wood door fronts that allow you to store things out of sight for a tidy vibe.

  • Choosing from among standard cabinet system options can simplify the process of kitchen design.

Cabinets-vsPic-03.jpg

2. Are there any downsides to traditional kitchen cupboards?

 

As with every design option, there are trade-offs when you go the route of modular kitchen cabinets. Picking the right product for your home is all about finding the benefits that mean the most to you and the downsides you can live with. Let’s look at some of the reasons a homeowner might explore other options than a traditional set of kitchen cupboards..

  • Sets of matching built-in cupboards do not have the charm of older kitchens that combine a variety of furniture style cabinets and wall shelves.

  • With everything hidden behind wooden doors, you may have to spend more time looking for what you need in a given moment.

  • A set of kitchen cabinets tends to be more expensive than a set of wall shelves for the same size kitchen.

  • Unlike simple shelves, the cabinets you choose typically define your kitchen’s style, and they may become dated.

  • Wood cabinet doors near the sink may be subject to damage from water drops.

3. Why are open shelves preferred by some designers and families?

Open shelving appeals to people because it keeps everything visible and accessible AND because items tastefully arranged on shelves give the kitchen more character than rows of matching cupboard doors. For example, with open shelves, you won’t search multiple cupboards for a single item, and you can always skip the step of opening and shutting a door when you need a dish or ingredient. If you’ve been drooling over cute kitchen photos that showcase shelves lined with adorable stacks of bowls interspersed with quaint pitchers and vases of flowers, you might be anxious to try this look in your own space.

HGTV’s Erica Reitman lays out “8 Reasons You Should Try Open Shelving in Your Kitchen,” and these include:

  • Shelves allow you to create multiple vignettes and even change them with the seasons.

  • Open kitchen shelves motivate you to keep your belongings organized (because everyone can see them).

  • If you’re a collector, the shelves give you a place to show off your treasures.

  • If any or all of these benefits appeal to you, explore open shelving options before committing to cabinets as your only form of kitchen storage.

For a custom glass alternative.png
 

3. Why are open shelves preferred by some designers and families

Open shelving appeals to people because it keeps everything visible and accessible AND because items tastefully arranged on shelves give the kitchen more character than rows of matching cupboard doors. For example, with open shelves, you won’t search multiple cupboards for a single item, and you can always skip the step of opening and shutting a door when you need a dish or ingredient. If you’ve been drooling over cute kitchen photos that showcase shelves lined with adorable stacks of bowls interspersed with quaint pitchers and vases of flowers, you might be anxious to try this look in your own space.

HGTV’s Erica Reitman lays out “8 Reasons You Should Try Open Shelving in Your Kitchen,” and these include:

  • Shelves allow you to create multiple vignettes and even change them with the seasons.

  • Open kitchen shelves motivate you to keep your belongings organized (because everyone can see them).

  • If you’re a collector, the shelves give you a place to show off your treasures.

  • If any or all of these benefits appeal to you, explore open shelving options before committing to cabinets as your only form of kitchen storage.

Cabinets-vsPic-03-B.jpg

4. What materials are kitchen shelves made of?

 

Kitchen wall shelves are typically made from:

  • wood

  • glass 

  • stainless steel

  • steel wire

In her post, “5 Types of Open Kitchen Shelving: Which One Fits Your Kitchen?” Brooke of Plank & Pillow highlights a few types of wooden and glass shelves. For example, floating wooden shelves combine a more rustic material with a modern installation method. Likewise, metal systems can hang from the ceiling and suspend wood or glass shelves for a beautiful combination of materials. She introduces a specific application of glass shelving in which it is installed in front of the kitchen window for a radiant blend of glass and sunlight with the items on the shelves seeming to float in midair. 

Glass is an appealing material for kitchen applications because it isn’t susceptible to moisture damage and won’t be stained by spills. Glass shelves can be customized by a shop such as ABC Glass & Mirror.  Homeowners value the shelves’ ability to combine style and storage, a feature that makes them appealing for outfitting a kitchen. The dimensions, placement, hanging/support system, and glass style are up to you. Clear glass is a popular choice that matches all décor and gives the kitchen a sense of spaciousness. Its smooth exterior also simplifies dusting and sanitizing. However, several other glass styles are offered if you want a somewhat different look.

  • Acid -etched: This glass has a consistently frosty look across its exterior. It also matches many decorating modes and is great for preserving a historic feel in a vintage kitchen.

  • Patterned: Glass can also have an abstract or pictorial textured pattern on its surface for shelves with lots of character.

  • Tinted: Bronze and gray tinted glass can also be used for custom shelving with a hint of color.

Moving on to metal options, we have wire shelving and stainless steel shelves. If you’re looking to outfit your kitchen in the most budget-friendly way, wire shelves are a very appealing option. The lower price tag is a plus, but most would not consider the shelves themselves to be as attractive as wood or glass alternatives. However, this can be mitigated by using warmer materials elsewhere in the kitchen and by thoughtfully styling the items on the shelves. Solid stainless steel shelves also evoke commercial kitchens. However, they are more sleek than wire shelves and can create a very clean, futuristic vibe.

Cabinets-vsPic-04.jpg

5. Are there disadvantages to wall shelves in a kitchen?

 

Like cabinetry, wall shelves have a lot going for them, but there are trade-offs to consider with this product, too. Common concerns about replacing cupboards with open shelves include:

  • Items are vulnerable to dust and to grease.

  • If you don’t keep everything tidy and styled, a kitchen with open shelves will look messy.

  • Filling a cupboard to the max won’t affect your kitchen’s appearance, but overfilled shelves are unattractive.

  • Some items that are stored in a kitchen – like canned vegetables or cereal boxes, for example – just don’t look nice on display.

  • Fragile items like glassware are more vulnerable to damage when exposed on a shelf instead of tucked behind a protective door.

If this list has dampened your excitement about the design possibilities offered by wall shelves, keep reading for ways to work around these issues.

Cabinets-vsPic-05.jpg

6. How could I mitigate these disadvantages if I really want to try open shelving?

 

For homeowners who love the charm and convenience of open shelving but fear the practical drawbacks, a combination of cabinets and wall shelves can be the perfect solution. In fact, it is rare to totally eschew kitchen cabinets. Even hardcore open shelving aficianados tend to keep the lower cabinets while replacing the upper ones with shelves. Why? For one thing, families with little ones want to keep some kitchen items behind child-locked cupboard doors. Also, it’s true that your kitchen will look cuter with some things out of sight. After all, does anyone really want to create a vignette that includes boxes of sandwich bags and rolls of aluminum foil?

 

Here are some tips for successfully using both cabinets and open shelves in one kitchen.

  • Add only enough shelves for storing the items you’re happy displaying. Popular picks include canisters, mugs, dishware, and glassware. However, it may be best to showcase only a curated assortment of these things.

  • Also consider using shelves (or a hanging rack) for items that you use frequently and would like to make more accessible.

  • Consider how many shelves worth of stuff you will be able to keep dusted and arranged. You can always start with just a few and then add more open shelves if it’s going well.

Cabinets-vsPic-06.jpg

7. What if I like the benefits of open shelving but am not ready to tear out any cabinets?

 

It’s true that tearing out ANY kitchen cabinets can be daunting. After all, these aren’t cheap items...not to mention the fact that you’ll need to fill holes and sand and paint the walls where the cabinets were removed. Let’s explore three ways to enjoy some or all of the benefits of open shelving without taking out a single cabinet.

  • In her aforementioned article, Erica Reitman suggest dabbling in open shelves by adding them to unused kitchen walls, such as the space around a doorway. Assuming you have some available wall space, this is a win-win: more storage, a chance to arrange adorable vignettes, and no loss of cupboard space.

  • If this option isn’t possible or desirable for you, Erica points out that removing the doors from one or more cabinets is another risk-way free way to see if open shelving is for you. (Besides actually removing doors, you’ll want to fill any screw holes and thoroughly clean the cabinet’s interior.)

  • A third option we would recommend is replacing some of your wooden cupboard door fronts with clear cabinet glass. While this won’t look quite the same as open shelving, you get to keep benefits like dust-protection but still stylishly display your pieces.

If cabinet glass sounds like the best of both worlds, learn more by getting answers to FAQs about this product.

Q-icon.png

What glass styles are available for cabinet glass?

A-icon.png

Cabinet glass from ABC Glass & Mirror can be clear, acid-etched (frosted), patterned, or tinted (bronze or gray).

Q-icon.png

Should I have all my cupboard door fronts replaced with glass?

A-icon.png

It’s up to you. Many homeowners will choose select cupboards to update with clear cabinet glass, fill these with items they want to show off, and leave the original door fronts in place elsewhere. However, if you want a new look throughout the kitchen, you can use clear cabinet glass on some cupboards and vision obscuring glass on others.

Q-icon.png

If the insides of some of my cupboards are going to be visible, how can I make them look more appealing?

A-icon.png

Besides the obvious step of cleaning the cupboard’s interior, you can replace old wooden shelves with custom glass shelves for a fresh look. The back wall of a cabinet can be spruced up with contact paper or a few coats of paint. The finishing touch is to style the items on the cabinet shelves.

Cabinets-vsPic-07.jpg

8. Do shelves or cabinets harmonize better with certain types of décor?

 

A final matter to consider before making your decision is the style you want for the kitchen. Cabinets are so universally popular that they are at home in kitchens of all styles – modern, transitional, classic, industrial, and so forth. Likewise, wall shelves are such a timeless fixture that they meld harmoniously with any kitchen design, too. 

However, if you are trying maintain the historic vibe of a period home, this is another reason to include at least some wall shelves in your design. As Nancy Mitchell points out in her piece on the history of open shelves, people used to outfit their kitchens piece by piece, gradually adding walls shelves, cabinets, and work tables as needed. Including free standing cabinets and open shelves can keep the kitchen in line with the rest of an antique home. For example, check out all the open shelves in the photos of this restored Victorian era kitchen featured in Old House Journal Online.

Finally, a combination of traditional cabinets and open shelving is perfect for those who favor the recent trend away from minimalism. Open shelves give you a place for the layered and eclectic (but thoughtfully curated) displays that make a room more personal. Wall shelves or cabinets with clear glass doors are practically a must-have for kitchens in these styles:

  • Grandmillenial

  • Maximalist

  • Cottagecore

  • Shabby chic

Cabinets-vsPic-08.jpg
 

9. What is the best way to arrange items on open shelves?

Successfully styling the contents of kitchen wall shelves is all about blending visual appeal and functionality. Jessica Bennett of Better Homes & Gardens breaks the process down into five easy steps. First, “[e]dit down your collection” by choosing only the items you use daily and would like keep handy. Next, find “other items” that will add beauty and charm to the display. Third, arrange “items on shelves according to use” by putting things you use often on the lower surfaces. Fourth, remember to “[v]ary size and scale”  by placing large items first, then medium pieces, and finally the smallest objects as finishing touches. Last but not least, include the “under-shelf area” by continuing the display on the surface below the bottom shelf. Check out Jessica’s full article for more details on each step.

More tips for success include:

  • Decide on a color scheme for your display. One technique is to pair a neutral and a bold color and use a third shade as an accent tone. Looking at a few of your favorite pieces might suggest a color palette.

  • Include a variety of materials for more visual interest. For example, a shelf full of dishes will be more aesthetically pleasing if you intersperse some wood, metal, or glass items. Wooden bowls, spoons, and cutting boards; glass pitchers and bottles, and metal mugs and canisters are all good options.

  • Keep the display simple enough that cleaning it will be possible and invest in a flexible duster so you can give it quick touch-ups as needed.

Cabinets-vsPic-09.jpg
 

10. How can I tastefully style items behind clear glass door fronts?

If you prefer cupboards with clear cabinet glass to open shelves, many of the same techniques can be used to showcase your items. There are a few additional points to consider when working with cabinets, though.

  • The back and side walls inside the cabinets offer you more design possibilities. Paint, stencil, or paper these to draw the eye to the display.

  • Consider adding stick on LED lights inside the cabinets to highlight your collectibles or other treasures.

  • Keeping the cabinet glass clean and sparkly is crucial for maintaining the display’s aesthetic appeal, so form a weekly routine and spot clean as necessary in between.

  • Stacks of plates and bowls can get boring, so consider topping some of the stacks with a more decorative item such as a cream pitcher, vase, or figurine.

Cabinets-vsPic-10.jpg

11. How can I learn more about the process of adding glass shelves or cabinet glass to my particular kitchen?

 

If glass shelves or cabinet glass would help you add beauty, style, and convenience to your kitchen, you may wish to schedule a free in-home consultation with a custom glass expert. ABC Glass & Mirror of Manassas Park, VA specializes in glass installations tailored to the customer’s needs and design goals. We’ll send a glazier to your home to show you samples and pictures, go over product options, take the necessary measurements, and answer any questions you may have. After the consultation, the process follows these general steps:

  • Receive an emailed price quote for the job.

  • Make your decision and call in your order.

  • Set up the installation appointment with us.

  • Relax as a trained team of glass experts puts your shelves and/or cabinet glass in place.

  • Create beautiful kitchen displays that perfectly meld storage and style.

Call ABC Glass & Mirror at (703)257-7150 to get started!

Cabinets-vsPic-11.jpg